This a poll asking if Peyton Manning should return for one more year. Peyton Manning is probably the best regular season quarterback in NFL history but he has “only” one Super Bowl win. John Elway hired his former backup quarterback Gary Kubiack to be the new Broncos coach and that may weigh in Manning’s decision to come back.
Peyton Manning was injured during the last weeks of the season and he played badly. He looked rubber armed in the playoffs loss and you have to wonder if he just got old. If Peyton Manning can regain his early season form I think he should come back for another season.
If the Peyton Manning we saw at the end of the season is what he is now, then he needs to retire in my opinion. The challenge of designing a new offense with Kubiack may fire Peyton Manning up to come back. Of course the draft and free agent moves of the Broncos will probably determine whether or not Peyton Manning retires as well.